What you see here is precisely what you think it is: TMC's little brother, The Sadist's Room. With my mind completely shattered from all the bad anime I get to review for TMC, this room will serve as a relief, a place where I can legitimately butcher and perform an autopsy on all the better titles that you suggest me.
The rule, again, is really simple. You give me a title of any anime/manga (anime no longer than 26 episodes, manga without limitations), I will then watch/read it, review it and rate it. This time, it's not about the bad anime - it's about the anime that seemed so miniscule/niche/uninteresting and yet positively surprised you, the ones that are legitimately good and everyone knows it, basically - the titles you'd suggest others to watch.
This time, however, when requesting, give one reason for suggesting it and tell me how long it is.
How will I rate them? This time, the system is not really that hard to read.
Progress bars. Know them? Well. As I feel it's not up to me to decide on what's good and bad about the anime, this time I will not split the reviews in sections, but rather review them as a whole. At the end of each review, you'll see a progress bar, like the one above. It'll be colored on the scale from red, via yellow/orange, to green, with darker colors being obviously better than their light counterparts. I will not spell out the rating as x/20, but rather have you visually able to rate it on a similar level, why - because I want you to feel that my scale is more-or-less accurate in my eyes, not precise. With the final verdict, obviously, still intact.
Interesting? Then let's get this show on the road!
Suggest your own anime or manga below.